If we are obliged to follow their Sunnah, then we must know who they are. He is a very good brother but he has some odd views that no scholar before him adopted or he adopts views oppose what scholars are upon sometimes. Because there might come a neccessity for taking some unique decisions which didnt have clear evidence from the wordings of Prophet Saw , like reviving the sunnah of taraweeh, waging war against those who reject from paying zakat, etc. Login or Sign Up. Even though he ruled the Ummah for half a year and was heavily praised by the Prophet sallallahu ‘alayhi wa sallam.
|Date Added:||14 November 2012|
|File Size:||36.38 Mb|
|Operating Systems:||Windows NT/2000/XP/2003/2003/7/8/10 MacOS 10/X|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Alaikum bi Sunnati | Urdu Books PDF
He did not mention anything else. I mean its authenticity is disputed. Ibn Fulan the Sufi: Forums Blogs Articles Groups. Examples like the opinion of Ibn Omar who did not pray Jama’ah prayer in the qiyam of Ramadhan, his opinion with regards to mot’a al hajj, which differed with Abu Bakr AND Omar or Alaikum bi sunnati Abbas and his famous saying and many Sahaba who differed with the Khulafa’, and as the quote says, who are the Khulafa Alaikum bi sunnati Rashidin in the first place, if sticking to them is wajib, then we must know who they are, most books don’t even mention Al Hassan Ibn Ali as the 5th Khalifa, rather they mention Omar Ibn Abdel Aziz!
Originally posted by Abumisbah View Post.
Also the quote from Ibn Abbas. Is the defention of Sunnah – words, action or approval applied here??
Hadith: “‘Alaykum bi Sunnati wa Sunnat Khulafaa’ – Multaqa Ahl al-Hadeeth
Login or Bu Up. If we are obliged to follow their Sunnah, then we must know who they are. Even though he ruled the Ummah for half a year and was heavily praised by the Prophet sallallahu ‘alayhi wa sallam. What about the hadith where the prophet said to follow the quran?
Originally posted by al-Baseerah View Post. Please share your stuff and information, baarakallah feekum.
Previous 1 2 Next. This topic is closed. He is a very good brother but he sunnari some odd views that no scholar before him adopted or he adopts views oppose what scholars are upon sometimes. Do not read to the brother who posted that post in the Arabic Multaqa. Originally posted by Al-Daylami View Post.
Alaikum Bi Sunnati By Shaykh Mufti Abdul Hakeemr.a
I’ve read on alaikum bi sunnati Arabic Multaqa: Because there alakkum come a neccessity for taking some unique decisions which didnt have clear evidence from the wordings of Prophet Sawlike reviving the sunnah of taraweeh, waging war against those who reject a,aikum paying zakat, etc. The quran only tells us to follow the prophet and no one else.
He is not a scholar after all though he is a student of knowledge. Dont you think they contradict each other?
Ibn Omar said in some narrations explicitely like Mot’a of Hajj and ‘Umra that he disagrees with his father, same with Taraweeh. If I do not greet back in writing then know I do it verbally because sometimes I am too busy and just want to answer alaikum bi sunnati question. Also the poster on the Multaqa states that besides it weakeness in the Sanad, it is also weak matnan, for it gives the authority of tashree’ to other than Allah and his Messenger, i.
Today’s Posts Member List Calendar.